An End of Era Feeling:

On The Blue Angel

By

Ian Buruma

Symposium Participants: Ian Buruma

   It is tempting to see Josef von Sternberg’s masterpiece, The Blue Angel, made in 1930, as a prophetic vision of what was about to happen in Germany. The movie—about the degradation of a provincial schoolmaster, whose smug belief in his moral probity based on classical tradition and Prussian discipline goes to pieces when he falls for the sexual allure of a cheap cabaret singer—seems to signal the collapse of high bourgeois Germany followed by the total depravity of the Third Reich.

Of course, neither von Sternberg, nor anyone connected to the film, could have known what lay in store. Artists are not prophets. In 1930, the Nazi party was growing in power, especially in such rural states as Thuringia and Saxony, but the Social Democrats were still the largest party; the old war hero, Paul von Hindenburg, was President of the Weimar Republic, and Bertolt Brecht could still put on his plays. Brownshirts and Communists were brawling in the streets of Berlin, the economy was pretty catastrophic, but few people would have predicted that Germany would be a murderous dictatorship just three years after The Blue Angel was made.

The dangerous attractions of dissolute sexuality and the social corruption that made Weimar Berlin so notorious came earlier anyway, in the wake of Germany’s defeat in World War One, which destroyed the moral certainties of Wilhelminian Germany. In fact, if anything, it was Heinrich Mann, author of the novel, Professor Unrat (Professor Filth) upon which the movie was loosely based, who was prophetic. His novel appeared in 1905, when high bourgeois Germany was at its zenith. Mann, unlike his more conservative brother Thomas, was a leftist critic of bourgeois culture, which he regarded, with good reason, as hypocritical, greedy, and corrupt under the veneer of high culture, humanistic ideals, and puritanical family life. In Mann’s novel, Professor Raat, nicknamed Unrat, Filth, by his students, falls for the charms of “Rosa Fröhlich, artiste.” After being socially disgraced by his behavior, he takes his revenge on the fine, upstanding people in his town who fomented his disgrace by running a gambling operation that impoverishes and corrupts them all.

21

   Rosa Fröhlich, artiste, became Lola in the movie, played brilliantly by Marlene Dietrich. Sternberg, with Mann’s approval, cut the revenge part of the novel and stripped it down to the professor’s humiliating downfall. The professor is acted by the great Emil Jannings, the burly giant of German theater and film. In the movie version, the ruined professor has none of the malice of the character in the novel. He is absurdly pompous, but his authority in the classroom is comical, rather than malign. If he is tyrannical to his students, he is a fragile tyrant, easy to make fun of behind his back. Above all, he is a man of flesh and blood, whose sensual desires are unblocked in the worst possible circumstances.

Sternberg, unlike Mann, was not particularly interested in political criticism. As a Jewish immigrant in the US (the aristocratic “von” in his name was a bit of self-invention), Sternberg was unconcerned about the corruptions of German bourgeois life. His twist of the story was erotic. Lola and Unrat are like figures in a fin-de-siècle play about a femme fatale and her victim, locked in a liaison that can only end very badly. While shooting The Blue Angel, Sternberg and Dietrich became lovers; Lola would be the first of several femme fatales played by Dietrich in Sternberg movies, one more lethal and glamorous than the other. Lola is a tawdry cabaret singer. Dietrich would go on, in 1934, to play an eroticized Catherine the Great. Even though it would be an error to see The Blue Angel as a prophetic film, Sternberg is a master at foreshadowing what is going to happen to his characters. The movie opens with a market place full of loudly squawking chickens. When the professor goes mad at the end of the film, he screeches like a tortured chicken being plucked alive.

Immediately following the tumult of the chicken market, we are in Unrat’s classroom, where he still reigns supreme, his pupils jumping to attention the moment he appears in his long black schoolmaster’s robes. His beady eyes scour the schoolroom for any sign of disobedience. The tiniest lapse in moral character will be punished severely.

ternberg had a lot of trouble with Jannings, whose preening vanity was matched by deep insecurity. Tantrums would erupt the moment he sensed that Sternberg was paying even a little more attention to Dietrich than to himself. But out of their personal tensions a great performance emerged, perhaps the greatest Jannings ever gave on film. His large expressive face and the way he moves his ungainly body show the fastidiousness of an awkward, repressed, lonely man, who desperately needs to keep up his air of authority. The dainty way he delicately slips sugar into his coffee tells you so much about his petty bourgeois pretentions.

The first cracks in the professor’s orderly world begin to appear when he follows some of his pupils to the sordid music hall where Lola is performing. His intention is to save his pupils’ morals by catching them red-handed in that den of vice. As soon as Unrat leaves the narrow confines of classroom and rented lodgings, he is in another world of dark seedy streets and shady people, prostitutes and sailors, shot in the shadowy higgledy-piggledy manner of German expressionism.

On the stage, fat, half-naked women sway with the raucous music and Lola sings her suggestive songs, while showing off her shapely legs. In the dressing-room, the professor encounters clowns, dancing girls, and Kiepert, the plump oily manager of the troupe. Kiepert, played by the sublime Kurt Geron, is astonished and then flattered by the presence of a grammar school professor. “Art and education,” he intones, “what a perfect combination”.

Mutual flattery is the prelude to the disasters to come. When Unrat attempts to protect Lola from the attentions of a drunken sea captain, who is used to buying her favors, she is astonished and then rather moved. No man ever did such a thing for her. Unrat, not used to attracting any kind of female attention, is shaken by Lola’s flirtations.

The professor quickly loses his moral bearings in this unfamiliar world of tinsel, sex for sale, and loud popular music, performed by Weintraub-Syncopators, one of the most popular jazz bands of the Weimar years. He still retains the formal manners of a bourgeois gentleman, but they are grotesquely misapplied. He formally asks Lola for her hand.

A family member of the cabaret troupe, Unrat gamely clucks like a chicken when Kiepert, the manager, conjures eggs from the professor’s nose and ears at the wedding celebration. Without his position as a teacher, a social outcast among his peers, the professor is reduced to peddling salacious postcards of his wife to drunken cabaret audiences. Lola is half-amused by his gradual degradation, but increasingly contemptuous. Kiepert then decides to make Unrat perform as a clown onstage, squawking like a chicken, when eggs are broken on his bald pate.

When he is told by a gleeful Kiepert that the troupe will perform in Unrat’s home town, that the show is already sold out, and that everyone, from his former pupils and grammar school colleagues to the town’s mayor, will be there, Unrat refuses to perform. Kiepert forces him to do so anyway. The public, warmed up by the girl dancers, call for “the professor, the professor!” As Unrat is pushed onto the stage, he glimpses his wife cuckolding him in her dressing room with the troupe’s “strongman.” On stage, Kiepert taps the clown’s head and pronounces it empty, then cracks open one egg, then another, then a third. Unrat refuses to squawk. The audience is restless. Kiepert gets angry. Then Jannings erupts in an insane screech that turns the squawk of a chicken into a howl of sheer madness. He has lost his mind.

All the members of the troupe, Kiepert, the strongman, the other clowns, the dancing girls, Lola herself, recoil in horror. Lola backs away from the mad professor, who tries to attack her, and says: “It’s not my fault. I didn’t do anything!” She goes onstage and sings her famous song, Falling in Love Again, but this time her languid sensual appeal turns into a kind of hard sneer, at the foolishness of men who fall for her.

19

   We see Unrat’s hulking form stumbling through the back alleys of the dark side of town, towards his old school, where, still in his clown’s makeup, he finds his way to his old classroom, where the janitor finds him dead at his old desk.

Everything about this extraordinary movie works. The script, written by Carl Zuckmayer and Robert Liebmann, is perfect. The expressionist style, full of dark shadows and odd angles, is beautifully shot by Günther Rittau. Jannings, Dietrich, Geron, Hans Albers as the strongman, and the rest of the cast, are terrific. The score, composed by Friedrich Hollaender, is wonderful.

Many great films were made at the UFA studios in the 1920s. Fritz Lang’s M, Pabst’s Pandora’s Box, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, by Robert Wiene, are all masterpieces. But The Blue Angel, directed by an American Jew, is in many ways the crowning achievement of Weimar period cinema. Rather than foreshadowing what was to come, this movie, more than any other work of art, expresses the moral collapse that followed World War One, accompanied by grotesque economic inequality, a great deal of political and criminal violence that would only get worse, and a burst of extraordinary artistic creativity. I don’t think Sternberg viewed his subject, which was really Weimar Germany, with the eyes of a critic, let alone a moralizer. He was fascinated by the seductions and the dangers of sexual desire, by the spectacle of degradation, by the dark human impulses behind the glittering surface, and by the femme fatale. He, too, like Professor Unrat, fell hopelessly for Marlene Dietrich.

That The Blue Angel (like M, which came out one year later) was made just a few years before the Weimar republic collapsed and Hitler took total power, gives the film an end of era feeling. Even if the makers of the movie couldn’t have known this then, we can see it now. The sense of imminent doom, of a dazzling party ending in a nightmare of madness and death, hangs around the film like a cloud of toxic perfume. Some of this is hindsight, of course. But there was so much German art of the 1920s that was not so much gloomy as jittery, the product of a society that was unstable, like those expressionist images, unhinged, and doomed.

For many of the people who helped to make The Blue Angel such a great film, this was literally true. Dietrich left Germany for a Hollywood career. Jannings would compromise himself by appearing in Nazi propaganda movies in the 1940s. Friedrich Hollaender, the composer, was Jewish and forced to flee Germany in 1933. The Weintraub Syncopators, Jewish, left for Australia. Robert Liebmann, who wrote the lyrics of Dietrich’s songs, Jewish, was murdered in Auschwitz. As was Kurt Geron, Jewish, who was first taken to the Theresienstadt camp, where he was forced to make a propaganda film for the Nazis, and then to Auschwitz, where he was gassed.